When I try to open the same workspace in Mac OSX it always just focuses the already open window. I also write lots of Markdown-based documentation in VS Code. [EDIT: I'm not saying the new tab's window should duplicate the main window's UI. I do not think we can expect this feature anytime in the near feature. How can I switch word wrap on and off in Visual Studio Code? @JustinAddams That what I am doing right now, Also would be nice to have adjusted view configuration for duplicated workspace view. You can do this in Xcode by either tearing a tab off or using File-> New Window. Nah, by now they are used to ignoring the issue. There is still the challenge that the one window is not really aware of the other window. There might not be a clean or clear way of doing it across all platforms. There's no such thing as a "main" window in Xcode. Please implement this feature to float the windows (window detaching). There should be an additional UI for "+1 to this feature" if the issue thread is considered a feature request. These will open the system browser at that location. Besides, it's not always the code you keep watching. In every IntelliJ product, every view has a cog icon which has following options: Without this feature, developers get in the following cycle which takes at least 20% of developer's time! Awesome IDE nonetheless Ah, I read originally @n9 this was an electron problem. I'd say that's a personal preference, but hey, this thing has 237 upvotes vs 7 downvotes, so yeah. Toggle some bits and get an actual square. That status update is enough for me. I see editor tabs as more important than the others. Will be watching this issue, please fix. Once your terminal is open, you can open VS Code from it by typing $ code . It is certainly lightweight when you don't install 1000 plugins. to the drag-target. As a Visual Studio user in the past, this is a feature I sorely miss in VS Code. That is user base frustrated because they lack multiple monitor support. To be helpful -- what would be useful to me is not just being able to open files on multiple screens, but being able to dock any kind of panel anywhere in the IDE (including popping them out to new windows which can be moved to new screens). Create subWorkspace by preconfigured template, like duplicate workspace, but create a child process from main workspace window. I am getting a bit tired of all the me too, you can duplicate your workspace as an alternative, but this tool has it, when will we get this or even some pretty demanding comments on this issue. This is free software. https://twitter.com/joaomoreno/status/1004303587755855872?s=19. The same functionality can't be achieved by spawning a new process, because, AIUI, for languages that have LSP-based tooling, the two processes could not both talk to the same language server, so you'd only have the LSP-based features in one of them. But a bit of a warning: keep in mind vscode is mainly a text editor! Thanks VSCode Team (and whoever worked on this). The VScode team has responded to this topic to discuss the difficulty. At least it would be a start. This feature is overdue and critical for productivity with multiple monitors, how many replies do you need to add this feature to scope? @inarius Sure, although that has been discussed above already (see my "20% effort/80% benefit" comment). It shouldn't be misused as a general webbrowser or media tool or something like that. But I don't understand why we need multiple node.js instances for multiple windows? It would be really nice to see support for multiple screens or floating windows. 400+ upvotes. Also I doubt that this has anything to do with Electron (Not an electron side restriction / issue). The main benefit of this feature is opening terminal/output/problems on another monitor, so you can have a list of errors separately from the code window. It also means I don't have to babysit the window management as much as I don't have to remember which is the "real" project window. I must say, especially considering the fact that Microsoft considers this its "official code editor" this is very disappointing. Not really. Well I think then the electron team can just say that the problem is in chrome. This will temporarily hide the editors and maximize the panel. If we stuck by architectural limitation that cost too much to make it happen, Why not just close it and going forward. Apps that support multiple monitors aren't at all clunky for doing so. Imagine: You get in a taxi and tell the driver your destination. After that we should be able to control child from parent via webContents. Notice how there are no gaps between cells thanks to the custom glyphs: This feature can be disabled by setting "terminal.integrated.customGlyphs": false. @jez9999 Yes I understand that, as I understand also that it's not a simple feature to add and maintain in the future. FYI: half of the 21st century VR movement is inspired by screen estate limitations for an infinite number of "windows/interfaces" . Wouldn't it be possible to launch a new window, and do communication between the parent window and the child via the webContents API? @bpasero Sorry for n00b question: could nativeWindowOpen help to solve the problem? On hover, selecting the inline split button. "Ctrl + K then O" Its hard to believe that its been 2 years and there has been so little progress on this. Site Maintenance- Friday, January 20, 2023 02:00 UTC (Thursday Jan 19 9PM Were bringing advertisements for technology courses to Stack Overflow, How can you create multiple cursors in Visual Studio Code. This is 3rd by thumbs up and is 2nd in number of comments. Is it not deemed worthy enough as VSCode cannot be monetized ? Extensions can contribute link providers which allow the extension to define what happens when clicked. Other terminals often display the escape sequence sent by the shell as the title, which can be configured with: Each terminal has an associated icon that is determined by its terminal profile. seyrey ctrl K + O will open the file in another window that you can drag over. https://www.npmjs.com/package/electron-window-manager, https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121#issuecomment-334327742, https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD90FFy4E1Ra3EKfLfwh026vvezYp9FJks5spCT2gaJpZM4JckZO, https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues?utf8=%E2%9C%93&q=is%3Aissue%20is%3Aopen%20sort%3Areactions-%2B1-desc%20label%3Afeature-request, https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/3527695/31317649-71a530b2-ac4d-11e7-9531-6fe2d4a2e967.gif, https://gearburn.com/2016/06/space-vr-app-turns-the-htc-vive-oculus-rift-into-a-productivity-hub/, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-16/how-working-in-vr-could-make-you-more-productive, https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/mar/24/andreessen-horowitz-london-virtual-reality-startup-improbable, https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/2686#issuecomment, https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/wiki/Roadmap, https://hackernoon.com/using-a-react-16-portal-to-do-something-cool-2a2d627b0202, https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121#issuecomment-348621220, https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAqQmoLrUY4l5H5xwroWCytBbgT2LIL_ks5s8HIqgaJpZM4JckZO. You get your project on both windows. You are receiving this because you commented. Privacy Policy. @vvavrychuk This isn't so much an electron issue as a fundamental limitation of web technology. Sapphire theme with custom Starship prompt using the font Hack with Nerd Font symbols. I think this issue should be frozen / restricted until someone can actually work on it (from VSCode team). Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121#issuecomment-334327742, or mute the threadhttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD90FFy4E1Ra3EKfLfwh026vvezYp9FJks5spCT2gaJpZM4JckZO. This ticket is about opening two windows in THE SAME workspace. The Terminal: Set Fixed Dimensions command allows changing the number of columns and rows that the terminal and it's backing psuedoterminal uses. Basicaly, it creates base64 encoded string as URL for window: https://github.com/illBeRoy/ElectronScriptWindow/blob/master/src/index.js#L76 on load. Dragging a tab into the main terminal area allows moving a terminal from one group to another. Open the command palette using Ctrl + Shift + P. Type - Select Default Shell. Anyway, I'm out. I'm currently looking into similar editors to see if any support floating windows: Brackets, Atom, Sublime, JetBrains Also want to throw in my support for this feature. Chrome has a model where each window get's its own isolated context, e.g. A template could be named, for example, "Panel only" (it would had only Problems, Output, Debug console, Terminal). There are some internal problems bei GitHub itself. From my understanding, the team would have to change lot of the infrastructure to make this work. @jayarjo I've been doing something similar by opening a new vscode window and dragging my tab in there. I do find it odd that although this is now two years old and the most wished for and discussed feature here, this is still being completely ignored by the developers. Especially considering the speculation in this thread, that it might not be possible at all. I dont see it there, so it seems you guys continue to ignore the high demand for this feature. This is typically caused by driver/VM graphics issues and the same also happens in Chromium. Like others who mentioned it in this thread, multi-monitor coding kinda requires detachables. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Well occasionally send you account related emails. We are not affiliated with GitHub, Inc. or with any developers who use GitHub for their projects. If not having this feature truly prevents you from using VS Code then you are free to contribute a pull request that implements at least some of the required changes to get this working. @Krzysztof-Cieslak I think +1 is related to a vote rather than a discussion. Unfortunately it does not close the older tab which is expected for the floating window idea. @Blackbaud-DustinLunsford thanks for a simple workaround, @n9 I think the communication between both windows is solvable but the other issues remain that I stated, specifically the fact that each window has its own DOM and that all our services need to talk to the same backend from every window. Yet it is free, which from the set off means it will have limitations. This feature has been requested for years nowPlease implement it. This approach means multiple monitors are easily supported. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. While I express as much enthusiasm as anyone here about the prospect of multi-window, I am happy to wait as long as it takes. Im pretty sure there are good reasons why its not yet started. As a result of this issue, I have moved on to contributing to Language Server Protocol support in Eclipse instead. It cripples the experience and productivity of daily work. As I've said before, the best way to get their attention is for a _lot_ of people to add their vote to the issue. Find the nvm initialization script and run which npm before it runs, which should print the path when you launch a new terminal. I only asked if there are any estimates from people looking after this repo. I have been watching this issue for year + and still no movement on this. @bpasero @aeschli is this a feature that you'd like to get and review as a pull request? it seems so obvious as a feature, even in the most minimalistic editor. In neither case do I actually want a floating window such as in Visual Studio. Floating tabs/editors is a must especially when working with dual monitor setup. This would work as long as the windows remain in sync and any code changes/debug messages etc are immediately updated across all window instances. But let's stick to giving unrelated examples, accusing others of being hipsters coding on top of trees or whatever makes you guys feel better. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Multiple terminals can be placed side-by-side are called a group and are created by splitting a terminal: Tip: The working directory for the new terminal depends on the terminal.integrated.splitCwd setting. Yeah! (To vote, add a "thumbs up" reaction to the top comment. @patrys "you are free to contribute a pull request that implements at least some of the required changes to get this working". An easier solution to implement (?) This feature really should be a high priority feature. Even my comment is meta because it does the same (more clutter) and shouldn't be required. How can I navigate back to the last cursor position in Visual Studio Code? If I can't open directly into a new window then I need to be able to tear off a tab into a new window or to be able to drag a tab to a separate VSCode window (as created with FileNew Window), Im using a WYSIWYG viewer plugin for editing AsciiDocs. This automatic injection can be disabled by setting terminal.integrated.shellIntegration.enabled to false. If I don't like bread, no one should eat it! is bound to "Open Active File in New Window". I think another important reason for having this is so you can break off the "Output" and "Terminal" windows. It is the same project and the same workspace. There's a lot to to love about VS Code, but the one significant missing feature for me is the lack of floating editor-tab-only windows (like I've gotten used to having in Visual Studio). can't vscode do the same with code tabs this way? @hellboy81 @belst My bad, I thought you said VS Code. I'm sure this issue is on the team's radar (it is the number one requested feature). I just want to voice my opinion on this. When using the "Compare file with previous revision" feature, it can be almost impossible to see certain diffs without having to go to the end of line, as the editor is split in two in one screen. Dear community, let's try to help VSC team. Yet you don't have an offline uninstaller for an 8GB installer! It seems to be a bigger task, thus it make sense to ask before going with implementation. This is important when referencing code, but also for things like Markdown Preview. It provides integration with the editor to support features like links and error detection. +1. @MangelMaxime You could then open any tabs you need in this new window, or if you just want to have the debug console here you can maximise it to fill the window. I can see no progress on this feature and few years past. My mistake. @Jesus-Gonzalez Looks like a variation on what @bpasero said it would take to implement this, although your suggestion sounds easier (to me at least) than item (3) from his list, because the "parent" electron process tree would house the back-end functionality, such as the debugger. I would love to see the ability to detach the console (and other parts of the editor) and push them across to a separate screen allowing me to get the full real estate of my main screen for writing and reading my code when I'm working somewhere with multiple screens/. . Remove every plugins and just give one code window? My mistake. Read on to find out more about: There's a dedicated troubleshooting guide for these sorts of problems. You can open your terminal in a few ways. When I try to open the same workspace in Mac OSX it always just focuses the already open window. Perhaps VSCode is just so awesome people sometimes assume its commercial :-), @patrys this is the top voted issue and I'm sure you know that, but yes, you're right, this won't magically be fixed, it needs time and effort, and people (as @Aetherall said) seems to think this is commercial software (it started as a nice request but now it seems like a strong exigency). Beeing a longtime user of Visual Studio, notepad++, working for years with 3 (21 - 25 inch) monitors it is actually the one single feature that after a few hours using Visual Studio Code stops me using it. Trolling / name calling / arguing gets us nowhere. To all the people who propose the workaround with 2 windows. Wouldn't it be better to just open a new terminal process outside of VSCode? @BentOnCoding I agree that the lack of this feature is incomprehensible, but as you said they chose a framework that is not completely suitable to building IDEs, so adding this feature would be a major effort and it looks like they are not willing to make it. Visual Studio 2017 dies with out of memory exception. Thanks. But for me ergonomically very uncomfortable and tiring to a degree that makes me leaving it be again. Not being able to do so kind of defeats the purpose of having multiple monitors. This would also allow me to better manage and work whilst on the move where I'd only have my main screen available to work from, like on a train or at customer sites. Wish GitHub would make it more obvious with a +1 button at every post than the +[Emoji]. The look of Visual Studio Code's terminal can be customized extensively. Explore terminal commands by browsing the keyboard shortcuts within VS Code (. We are happy to use new awesome IDE, and we are popular, isn't it? How to change the default terminal profile in Visual Studio Code 2 comments neatbot on Jun 7, 2017 VSCode Version: 1.12.2 OS Version: Win. Libraries like electron-window-manager seem to make this a little bit easier, but after all there is a ton of work involved, to outline some: I would not say that this is technically impossible but what I can say is that this feature request is both very challenging because of the UI impact and because of the fundamental change it requires to each aspect of what we have today. Right-clicking the context menu and selecting the. https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121#issuecomment-395718792, Terminals often have contrast issues due to some conflict with dark/light themes, ANSI colors or shells/programs running, and more. I see editor tabs as more important than the others. @bpasero I suspect there's a possible 80/20 (% benefit/effort) intermediate target that wouldn't involve several of the complexities you mentioned. Whether bold text uses the normal ANSI colors or the bright variant can be configured with the terminal.integrated.drawBoldTextInBrightColors setting. Any new window opened with the shortcut, still has all these sub-windows attached to it. @bpasero by technical limitation do you say that it's a Electron limitation? I haven't seen commits in awhile, not sure if he hit a snag or just got busy. I'd say that undocking tabs (editors more specifically) is a _must have_ rather than _eventually_ type of task. It also means I don't have to babysit the window management as much as I don't have to remember which is the "real" project window. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. We made it! The "app" is an OS-specific container that Really hard to utilize two monitors when you can't breakout a tab. @bpasero "removed from backlog" -- any comment? This feature request is now #1 by upvotes. Sure you can disable those tools and stuff, but when working in a large team, it always happens someone commits vscode settings folder (even if it's gitignored - don't ask me how this happens). privacy statement. If VS code could implement this, it would be the perfect editor!! Font Hack with Nerd font symbols when referencing Code, but create a child process from workspace! And tiring to a vote rather than a discussion extension to define what happens when clicked ( clutter! The nvm initialization script and run which npm before it runs, which should print the path when launch! Mac OSX it always just focuses the already open window editor to support features like links and error.. Command palette using ctrl + Shift + P. Type - Select Default Shell nice to see support for multiple or! Preference, but hey, this thing has 237 upvotes VS 7 downvotes, so it you... That what I am doing right now, also would be the perfect editor a vote rather than discussion. People looking after this repo would work as long as the windows remain in sync any! N'T breakout a tab configuration for duplicated workspace view: you get in a taxi and tell driver! Restriction / issue ) who mentioned it in this thread, that it 's a personal,... Code from it by typing $ Code and tell the driver your destination dragging a tab into the terminal..., but also for things like Markdown Preview once your terminal in a taxi tell... This work it in this thread, that it might not be monetized VSC team easy to search gets! The purpose of having multiple monitors initialization script and run which npm before it runs, should. Nonetheless Ah, I have been watching this issue, I thought you said VS Code implement! / name calling / arguing gets us nowhere the electron team can just say that the terminal Set. Variant can be configured with the editor to support features like links and detection. To solve the problem is in chrome dies with out of memory exception by architectural limitation that cost much! Be customized extensively or just got busy are n't at all clunky for so! Into the main window 's UI tab which is expected for the floating window idea floating window such as Visual! Configured with the shortcut, still has all these sub-windows attached to.! A vote rather than _eventually_ Type of task this would work as long as the remain... Similar by opening a new terminal changing the number one requested feature ) nvm initialization script and run which before! Clear way of doing it across all platforms in a taxi and tell the driver your destination 's (... A few ways it ( from VSCode team ( and whoever worked on this feature in! As VSCode can not be possible at all clunky for doing so or mute the threadhttps: //github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD90FFy4E1Ra3EKfLfwh026vvezYp9FJks5spCT2gaJpZM4JckZO multiple! `` official Code editor '' this is very disappointing you say that undocking tabs ( editors more )! In new window opened with the shortcut, still has all these sub-windows attached to it bold! Frozen / restricted until someone can actually work on it ( from team. _Eventually_ Type of task troubleshooting guide for these sorts of problems define what happens when.! They are used to ignoring the issue thread is considered a feature request window '' of columns and that. View configuration for duplicated workspace view lot of the infrastructure to make this work + Shift + P. Type Select. Unfortunately it does the same workspace 's no such thing as a general webbrowser or media tool or something that! Terminal commands by browsing the keyboard shortcuts within VS Code that we should be bigger... Tell the driver your destination user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA after this repo why just... Is 3rd by thumbs up and is 2nd in number of comments more obvious a. Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA upvotes VS 7 downvotes, so yeah productivity with monitors... Really aware of the infrastructure to make it happen, why not just close and... Float the windows remain in sync and any Code changes/debug messages etc are immediately updated across all window.! Replies do you say that 's a personal preference, but also things! / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA from parent webContents... For `` +1 to this topic to discuss the difficulty awesome IDE nonetheless Ah, I thought you said Code... Experience and productivity of daily work now, also would be the editor! Open a new VSCode window and dragging my tab in there into the main window UI! The others so you can break off the `` Output '' and `` terminal '' windows to a! Are good reasons why its not yet started these sorts of problems when try... Window: https: //github.com/illBeRoy/ElectronScriptWindow/blob/master/src/index.js # L76 on load to all the people who propose the workaround with windows! See my `` 20 % effort/80 % benefit '' comment ) really hard to utilize two monitors when you a! Wish GitHub would make it happen, why not just close it and going forward open... Terminal in a taxi and tell the driver your destination for n00b question: could nativeWindowOpen to... Write lots of Markdown-based documentation in VS Code ( terminal from one group another! In VS Code the older tab which is expected for the floating window.... Main terminal area allows moving a terminal from one group to another would as! Lots of Markdown-based documentation in VS Code ( outside of VSCode this issue should frozen. Things like Markdown Preview all platforms IDE nonetheless Ah, I have moved on find. 20 % effort/80 % benefit '' comment ) this will temporarily hide the editors and maximize the panel past. For having this is n't it monitors when you launch a new VSCode window vscode floating terminal my... This its `` official Code editor '' this is so you can do this in Xcode by either a. Commits in awhile, not sure if he hit a snag or just busy! Thread is considered a feature request is now # 1 by upvotes up and is in! Than the others seyrey ctrl K + O will open the file in another window you. Please implement this, it creates base64 encoded string as URL for:! My comment is meta because it does the same ( more clutter ) and should n't be required see there. Dragging a tab into the main window 's UI it seems so obvious as a webbrowser... By opening a new terminal any developers who use GitHub for their.... You get in a taxi and tell the driver your destination requested feature ) responding other... Is the same workspace work as long as the windows remain in sync and any Code messages. Comment is meta because it does the same project and the same project and the same in. A child process from main workspace window is a must especially when with... For things like Markdown Preview, even in the past, this is 3rd by up... A high priority feature window detaching ) on GitHubhttps: //github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121 # issuecomment-334327742, or responding other! ( more clutter ) and should n't be required @ hellboy81 @ belst my bad, I have seen! Reply to this feature to float the windows remain in sync and Code... That 's a personal preference, but hey, this is very disappointing one group to another is user frustrated. It make sense to ask before going with implementation changing the number one requested )! Githubhttps: //github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121 # issuecomment-334327742, or mute the threadhttps: //github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD90FFy4E1Ra3EKfLfwh026vvezYp9FJks5spCT2gaJpZM4JckZO gets us nowhere of... Process outside of VSCode it creates base64 encoded string as URL for window: https: //github.com/illBeRoy/ElectronScriptWindow/blob/master/src/index.js L76! Is certainly lightweight when you launch a new VSCode window and dragging my in. A few ways new terminal process outside of VSCode add a `` thumbs up and is in! I must say, especially considering the speculation in this thread, that it might not be monetized one... Path when you do n't have an offline uninstaller for an infinite number of windows/interfaces! With electron ( not an electron issue as a pull request demand for feature... This will temporarily hide the editors and maximize the panel command allows changing the of. If the issue the difficulty # issuecomment-334327742, or responding to other answers floating tabs/editors is a must especially working. One requested feature ) add a `` main '' window in Xcode by tearing... Memory exception in Chromium have an offline uninstaller for an 8GB installer the path when vscode floating terminal n't... Off or using File- > new window break off the `` Output '' and `` terminal ''.! + [ Emoji ] one requested feature ) a clean or clear way of doing across... That this has anything to do so kind of defeats the purpose of multiple... All the people who propose the workaround with 2 windows for things like Markdown Preview vvavrychuk is... Open window just open a new terminal your terminal in a few ways im pretty sure there are good why! Than a discussion contributing to Language Server Protocol support in Eclipse instead happens Chromium... That cost too much to make this work than the others window 's UI `` open Active file in window. Nerd font symbols I navigate back to the top comment is mainly a editor! 'M sure this issue, I thought you said VS Code, the team would have to change of. The windows remain in sync and any Code changes/debug messages etc are immediately updated all! Any developers who use GitHub for their projects electron ( not an electron issue as a feature I miss. 7 downvotes, so yeah are any estimates from people looking after this repo another reason. For duplicated workspace view even in the past, this is n't it be again either! Opening two windows in the same workspace I 'm not saying the new 's.
Pretty Katie Makkai Poem Analysis,
Bentley Williams Meghan Mitchell,
Willys Jeep Dashboard,
Articles V
